At our third meeting on November 28, 2018, we discussed the optimal timing of the math requirement for community college students to maximize their success. We read research on this from the article posted below, which concluded, interestingly, that completing the math requirement in either the first semester or in the fourth or fifth semester (for students followed over six semesters) maximized their chances of graduating within that three-year period. We spent the whole hour interpreting these results and debating possible explanations of the data, and concluded that the results might depend strongly on the previous preparation of the students. Well prepared freshmen might do better to take the math requirement immediately (and feel ready to register for it immediately); whereas less prepared students might experience more success by delaying the math requirement until they have completed a year of college and have experience in managing the academic expectations. The decrease in success for those taking math their last (sixth) semester might indicate students who remain underprepared to complete college-level math.